Tuesday, November 16, 2010

As the pendulum swings...

The question I chose to focus on was: Which pendulum will come to rest more quickly- a lighter pendulum or a heavier pendulum?

The materials I chose to use were the three different washers and the string that was provided for us. First I massed the washers using my kitchen scale, although it fluctuated some the masses were about 1g, 8g and 20g each. I then made a pendulum using the 1g washer. I tied the pendulum to a wooden skewer which I taped down to the wine rack so the pendulum could freely swing.

Pendulum set-up
At first I was trying to hold it, but thought that my own movement may have caused the pendulum to move. Since I did not have a protractor to measure the angle, I let it go from a 90 degree angle since this would be the easiest to estimate each time. I timed how long it took to come to complete stop. I repeated this twice for a total of three trials and averaged the times together. I then repeated this with the other two washers being very careful to make the pendulum the same length and dropping from the same place. The average time it took the pendulum to stop, in seconds, for the washers were 1g- 188s, 8g- 291s and 20g- 537s.  I then used the virtual lab to test this out as well. In the virtual lab I set up two pendulums simultaneously with the same length, but various masses and let them go at the same time and each time the lighter one came to a stop first when friction was added. My initial thoughts were that the heavier washer would come to a stop first, but I now understand after the application that the heavier washer has more momentum, therefore taking longer to stop.

The main problem I had was just trying to figure out how to set up the pendulum. It took a little bit of creativity of looking around my house to figure out where it could be placed. I wish I had had a protractor so I could have measured the angle so I would not have to wait as long for the pendulum to stop. In the classroom I would probably have the students explore the different things that affect the period of a pendulum- the length, the mass, and the angle of release. I would stress to the students about only changing one variable at a time. I would have the students offer suggestions for other things that could be used as the bob of the pendulum. I would have my students explore what pendulums have been used for-ie grandfather clocks. I would want my students to learn about momentum and how it can be applied to this situation. This gives them a more hands on approach. I would have them suggest other ways we could experiment with momentum and real world applications. I believe I achieved my goal of understanding momentum better. Overall going through the guided inquiry process helped me to gain a better understanding of not only how inquiry works and how our students my go about the process, but it also I gained a new perspective on the concept itself. Overall the inquiry process is something that should be used in the classroom to help our students become better scientists.
Pendulum in motion

5 comments:

  1. Hi Julie,
    I like your experiment. I agree that time can be an issue with inquiry activities. Some students seem to catch onto a concept quickly and are left waiting for other students to finish up the activity. I also like your connection to real world activities. Seeing pendulums in action really can help student connect with a concept.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You did such a great job with this experiment. It is clear you took your time, thought out your process, took clear notes on your observations, and really took the time to make an inference. It is clear you found the answer to the inital question. Great post.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Julie,

    I really enjoyed reading your post. You were very thorough in your experiment and I agree that allowing students to choose different objects for pendulums would provoke their interest even greater. It is key that the students only change one variable at a time, and it is even more important that the students realize the importance of changing the variable.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Julie,
    Love the pendulum activity! I did it with some very brave sixth graders in our school cafeteria with a bowling ball ball. These youngsters clearly and faithfully had to trust the laws of physics! I have done this experiment many times - but I still cringe when the ball hurtles toward the faces!!!! Keep up the fantastic work!
    What grade do you teach? I saw the book "Mr. Docker is off his Rocker!" I taught 3rd grade many years...Love that book:)
    Dave

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dave,
    Currently I do not have my own class, rather I am substituting at the schools on base and have been in classes from Sure Start through 5th grade. I was helping shelve books in the library one day and saw the book and had to read it. It was so much fun and can't wait to be able to read it my class one day.

    -Julie

    ReplyDelete